“We can be your agent” and “we can supply that” sound similar in a first call. They are different businesses. One sells work; the other sells goods. The contract, the price, the quality risk and the exit all change depending on which one you are actually talking to.
This is not an argument that one model is always better. It is an argument that you should know which model you are buying before you compare a percentage with a unit price.
The three models
1. Sourcing agent
The agent works for you. You contract with the factory — or the agent contracts in your name — and the agent is paid a fee for sourcing, verification, inspection, consolidation and follow-up. The factory price should be visible, and the agent should disclose any rebate or commission it receives from the supplier.
The agent does not normally take title to the goods. It manages the process and, in a financed programme, may pay the supplier on your behalf and collect from you later under a separate agreement.
2. Trading company
The trading company buys from the factory and resells to you. It takes title, sets its own price and carries the supplier relationship. You see one number, not the factory price plus a fee. That can be simpler, especially for small or highly fragmented orders, but it also hides the margin and can blur who is responsible when something goes wrong.
3. Buying office
A buying office is a captive team that works for one buyer or one group. It is not usually available to a new importer, and it is not the same as an independent agent. If a supplier says it has a “buying office in Europe”, ask who owns it and who it is legally obliged to represent.
Side by side
| Question | Sourcing agent | Trading company |
|---|---|---|
| Who is your contract with? | The factory, or the agent acting in your name | The trading company |
| Can you see the factory price? | Yes, normally | Usually bundled into one price |
| Who owns the quality dispute? | You, with the agent managing the claim | The trading company, subject to its contract |
| How is the margin charged? | A fee: per order or annual programme | A spread between buy and sell price |
| Best fit | Repeat orders, multiple suppliers, visible cost | Small orders, narrow categories, simple resale |
Why the cheapest quote is not the lowest cost
A trading company quoting 8% above factory cost and an agent quoting 3% are not directly comparable. The trading company may be carrying inventory, financing, inspection, a warehouse and the cost of returns. The agent's 3% may exclude inspection, freight, insurance and the time of the person who actually follows the order.
Compare the all-in landed cost and the scope. Ask what happens when a batch fails, who pays for the rework, who handles the claim and who is on the ground when the container is loaded. A low fee with no scope is not cheap; it is an unpriced risk.
Ten questions to ask either model
- Who is the contracting party on the purchase order, and who invoices me?
- Is the factory price disclosed, and do you take any rebate from the supplier?
- What exactly is included in your fee, and what is passed through at cost?
- Who inspects, against what standard, and what happens on a failed lot?
- Who is the importer of record, and who owns the customs and product-compliance file?
- How are payments released — deposit, balance, inspection, bill of lading?
- What is your liability if the goods are late or defective, in writing?
- Can I meet the factory, or at least see a live video walk-through?
- What is the notice period and the exit plan if I want to move?
- Can you give two references in my category, not just logos on a website?
When a trading company is the right answer
If you need 200 units, three colours and a single invoice, a good trading company can be faster and cheaper than building an agent relationship. If the product is tightly specified, the order is small and you do not want to manage a factory, the bundled price buys convenience. The mistake is assuming the bundle includes the same verification and recourse as a managed programme.
When an agent is the right answer
When you buy repeatedly, from more than one factory, and you want to see the cost structure. When the order is large enough that a 1–3% difference matters. When quality failures are expensive and you need someone on the ground before the balance is paid. When you want the option of 30–180 day terms without pretending the supplier is financing you for free.
Red flags in either model
- No written scope, no named person, no response time.
- A fee that only appears after you have committed to the order.
- Refusal to disclose the factory, or a factory address that does not match the licence.
- No inspection before the balance, or an inspection report with no photos and no measurements.
- A promise of 180-day terms with no insurer, no underwriting and no named funding source.
- Pressure to pay a deposit to a personal account or a third-party account.
The model matters less than the alignment. You want the party you pay to be the party that is accountable when the goods are late, wrong or unrecoverable. Put that in the contract, not in the brochure.