If a sourcing agent quotes 1% on a $200,000 annual programme, the fee is $2,000. That is not enough to verify suppliers, chase samples, book inspections, consolidate cartons, check documents and handle the after-sales argument when a container arrives wrong.
So one of three things is true: the agent is losing money on you, the scope is much narrower than you think, or the money is being made somewhere else in the quote. In most cases it is the third one.
This is not an argument that every low fee is dishonest. It is an argument that a percentage is meaningless until you know what it is a percentage of, and what is being earned outside it.
What 1% actually pays for
Take a simple $200,000 programme: ten orders of $20,000, five suppliers, two inspections per order. The work includes supplier identification, licence and factory checks, sample coordination, price negotiation, purchase orders, inspection booking, carton marking, consolidation, shipping documents and a claim when something goes wrong.
A conservative cost to serve that account is $6,000–$12,000 a year before any profit. A 1% fee of $2,000 does not cover it. A 3% fee of $6,000 is at the low end. A 5% fee of $10,000 is normal for a hands-on agent.
At $3 million a year, 1% is $30,000. That can fund a real team and a real scope. This is why “1%” is credible at scale and suspicious below it. The percentage did not change; the base did.
The three places the missing money hides
1. A supplier rebate inside the unit price
The agent tells you the factory price is $10.00. The factory actually quoted $9.60 and pays the agent 4% of the invoice. You never see the $0.40 because it is baked into the price you compare against other quotes.
This is the most common model in the industry, and it is not always disclosed. It becomes a problem when the agent is also supposed to negotiate the lowest price. If the agent earns more when the price is higher, the incentive is backwards.
How to detect it: ask for the factory's original quotation or proforma invoice, ask whether any supplier rebate, commission or marketing fee is paid, and ask for a written confirmation that the landed cost you see is the factory price plus the disclosed fee.
2. Freight, FX and insurance markup
The agent quotes “all-in logistics” at $4,800. The forwarder's real price is $4,200. The difference is not shown as a fee, so it does not show up in the 1% comparison. The same trick works with the exchange rate and the insurance premium.
How to detect it: ask for the forwarder's quote and the bill of lading charges, price FX at the bank rate on the invoice date, and ask for the insurer's debit note. A legitimate agent can show a pass-through with a small handling line.
3. A funding spread
The agent pays the supplier in 7 days and gives you 90 days to pay. The 1% fee looks tiny because the real revenue is the funding: 12–18% annualised on the amount advanced, sometimes described as a “service fee” rather than interest.
This is a legitimate business model — but it is a financing business, not a 1% agency. You should see the funding rate, the day count, the basis (advance amount or invoice value) and the insurance cost separately.
How to detect it: ask “what annual rate and day count are you using for the advance?” and “is the fee calculated on the FOB value or on the advanced amount?” If the answer is vague, the spread is the product.
When a 1% fee is real
A 1% fee can be a complete, honest fee when all of the following are true:
- Annual spend is large enough that 1% pays for the scope — typically $3 million or more.
- The scope is defined in writing: sourcing, verification, inspection, consolidation, documents, claims.
- Supplier prices are passed through with the factory quotation visible.
- No undisclosed supplier rebate, freight markup or FX spread.
- Funding and insurance are quoted separately, with a rate and a day count.
- The agent can lose the account for poor performance, not just for a cheaper percentage.
Our own published tier is 1% only at $3 million+ annual spend, with a $30,000 minimum. Below that, the fee is 1.5–5% because the work does not shrink with the invoice. The funding cost and insurance are separate lines. That is a less exciting headline than “1%”, but it is a number a buyer can audit.
Ten questions that expose a cheap quote
- Is the supplier price the factory's price, and can I see the original quotation?
- Do you receive any rebate, commission or marketing fee from the supplier?
- What exactly is included in the fee, and what is billed separately?
- Who pays the inspection, and what standard and sample size are used?
- Is freight a pass-through? Can I see the forwarder's quote?
- How is the funding cost calculated — rate, day count, basis?
- What is the insured limit, deductible and recourse position?
- Who is the contracting party, and who is liable if the goods fail?
- What happens if I want to change supplier or leave?
- Can you show the last three shipments where something went wrong and what you did?
If the seller will not answer questions 1, 2 and 6 in writing, the percentage is not the price. It is the advertisement.
What to do with this
Do not reject a 1% quote automatically. Put it next to a 3% and a 5% quote, convert all three to an all-in landed cost for the same order, and compare the scope line by line. The cheapest fee is often the most expensive quote once the rebate, freight and funding are added back.