Letters of credit are often presented as the “safe” option. They are safe for the supplier's payment. They are not necessarily cheap, fast or good for the buyer's working capital. Whether an LC or open account is better depends on the order, the supplier and your bank line — not on a general rule.
What an LC actually costs
- Margin: often 10%–30% of the LC value, blocked for the life of the LC.
- Issuance and amendment fees: typically 0.1%–0.5% per quarter, with a minimum.
- Line utilisation: the LC consumes an import line you may need for something else.
- Document checking: discrepancies cause delays, amendment fees and sometimes refusal.
- Management time: someone has to check the documents against the terms.
What open account actually costs
- Deposit: 20%–30% at order confirmation.
- Procurement fee: 1%–2% of annual spend.
- Funding: 8%–12% p.a. on the advanced amount.
- Insurance: 0.2%–0.8% of insured sales.
- Supplier management: included in the fee, or your own team's time.
A worked comparison
Assume a $500,000 order, 90 days, and a bank LC with a 20% margin at 6% p.a. cost of funds, 0.3% issuance and $1,500 in fees.
| LC | Open account | |
|---|---|---|
| Cash blocked | $100,000 margin | $125,000 deposit |
| Direct cost | ~$1,500 fees + ~$1,500 margin cost | ~$20,000 all-in |
| Bank line | Consumed | Not consumed |
| Supplier paid | On documents | On agreed schedule |
| Quality protection | None | Inspection + hold |
The LC looks cheaper on direct cost. But it does not free cash; it blocks $100,000 and consumes a line. The open-account route costs more in fees but keeps the line free and gives you 90 days after shipment. The right answer depends on what that line is worth to you and how much cash you need for inventory.
When an LC is the better tool
- One-off, high-value order with a new supplier.
- Supplier will not ship without bank security.
- Your bank line is cheap and underused.
- You need a documentary trail for a lender or a public tender.
When open account is better
- Repeat orders with known suppliers.
- Your constraint is working capital, not payment security.
- You want one set of documents and a predictable due date.
- You need inspection and supplier management in the same place as payment.
Do not choose on ideology. Model both. Then choose the one that costs less per dollar of cash freed, not the one with the lowest fee line.